Not Exactly Ana

Not Exactly Ana

How I Grew My Substack to 800+ Subscribers in 30 Days (Without Paid Ads)

A proven week-by-week strategy to grow your Substack audience, boost engagement, and attract paid subscribers—organically.

Not Exactly Ana's avatar
Not Exactly Ana
Oct 30, 2025
∙ Paid
41
5
8
Share

What’s the Real Strategy for Growing on Substack?

Here’s What Actually Worked for Me.

I believe more people deserve to hear the truth - not just fall for tactics that benefit someone else but bring no real value to you.

Step-by-step Substack publishing and promotion routine for creators in 2025

So today, I’m sharing what I learned in my first month on Substack - lessons and strategies that actually worked.

They helped me:

  • Grow my audience - from zero to 800 subscribers;

  • Increase engagement - with over 50+ comments across my posts;

  • Attract and retain PAID subscribers

  • To wake up the algorithm, even when it’s in “pause” mode;

  • Grow my income even when I’m sleeping;

    Substack growth Stats 2025 Google November Newsletter


Let’s be honest.

If there’s one thing I refuse to fall for on Substack, it’s the “Sub for Subs” propaganda.

It didn’t work on Instagram. It didn’t work on TikTok. And it definitely won’t work here.

Substack is a platform where people come for quality - not just numbers. You can’t expect that strategy to succeed here, and that’s perfectly fine.

Another myth is that the advice people give for Medium applies to Substack.

Sorry to disappoint, but these are two completely different platforms with two completely different algorithms. You can’t expect the same results.

I’ve tested both. Not a single dollar earned on Medium, while in the same time I was earning from Substack & growing my audience. And I wasn’t surprised!

Because the way my content appears there is nothing like how it shows up in Substack’s feed.

I hope more people realize this, so they stop chasing advice that’s based on someone else’s platform experience.


Week 1 – Learn the Platform Before You Chase Money

In my first week, I focused on understanding how Substack works. If I could go back, I’d do it all over again. This includes:

  • I spent time exploring the Dashboard & Settings;

  • I set my blog category - that’s how I target the right niche for me;

  • I customized my welcome email - my new subscribers recieved something meaningful from the start;

  • I also learned how to use Stats to track where my audience is located - this helped me build a posting schedule that actually aligned with peak hours for my readers.

    Substack growth strategy: how to gain 800+ subscribers in 30 days without paid adsSubstack growth strategy: how to gain 800+ subscribers in 30 days without paid ads

    Of course, I published content - three posts in that first week.

I’ll be honest with you - articles I believed would touch more people actually ended up with just 2–3 comments. It took time to realize that this is normal. Not everything we write will be successful, but we shouldn’t take it negatively.

On the contrary, accept it as experience.

You’ve researched, you’ve learned what’s being read at this stage - and if you’re still interested in writing on a topic that didn’t grab attention initially, you can always unpublish your essay and republish it later when you’ve built the right audience.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Not Exatcly Ana
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture